[On November 17, 1901, Lee Strasberg was born. He’d become one of the most influential figures in the history of American theater, so this week I’ll AmericanStudy him as part of a handful of significant stages in the development of that cultural form & space. Leading up to a special post on our exemplary theater program at Fitchburg State University!]
On what isn’t exactly the case with the experimental early 20C theater company, and why it might still be a part of the story.
Back in August 2015, as part of a series on Cape Cod Stories, I shared a blog post on Provincetown, which featured a middle paragraph on the Provincetown Players. My second and third paragraphs here follow directly on what I said in that prior paragraph, so please check it out if you would and then come on back for those continued thoughts.
Welcome back! In that paragraph, and indeed by including it in that post overall, I implied that the Provincetown Players were part of that Cape Cod town and community. But the truth, as I’ve learned more about in the years since, is that while they were indeed founded in Ptown in 1915 and performed for two summers there, after that they moved to New York City and spent their remaining seven years at their famous “Playwright’s Theater” on Macdougal Street in the Village. And it’s not just that the company and performances were located in a different place than that of their founding and name, but also and more importantly that their consistently experimental and radical choices had at least something to do with the blossoming Modernist scene in late 1910s and early 1920s New York City. To cite just one example, the 1920-21 season opened with a new play from founding member Eugene O’Neill: The Emperor Jones, which featured in its leading role Charles Gilpin, the first Black actor to perform with a mostly white company. The production ran for 200 performances, a hugely influential success that in 1920 was likely only possible (at least in the United States) in New York City.
So the Provincetown Players were, in some key ways, more the Macdougal Street Players. But at the same time, I think there remain some very good reasons to keep their Cape Cod origins prominent in how we remember this hugely influential theater company (I stand by my line, in that 2015 blog post, that they created “the first truly groundbreaking American dramatic forms and works”). For one thing, if you’ve read any Eugene O’Neill, you know that his plays include incredibly extensive paragraphs of stage directions and character descriptions, prose passages detailing both psychology and community that would make another product of the Massachusetts coast, Nathaniel Hawthorne, proud. And for another thing, to my mind the single most compelling text to emerge from the Provincetown company is Susan Glaspell’s Trifles (1916), a play (adapted a year later into a short story) that owes a great deal to the longstanding genre of New England local color writing. Which is to say, perhaps the best way to describe the Provincetown Players is that they took the traditions of 19th century American literature and helped bring them into new 20th century theatrical and cultural forms—making them a bridge worthy of Cape Cod indeed.
Next stage tomorrow,
Ben
PS. What do you think? Theater histories or stories you’d share?

Leave a Reply