[On October 23rd, the MLB World Series got underway. I’ve been thinking about baseball history a ton over the last few years, including for the two seasons of my podcast, so this week I’ve offered some AmericanStudies contexts for baseball playoffs over time. Leading up to this weekend post on takeaways from my latest podcast season!]
I’ve already mentioned Japanese American baseball a few times across this week’s series, and those figures and stories, communities and histories are all things I learned while researching, writing, and recording Diamond in the Rough: Baseball, Bigotry, & the Battle for America, season two. But there’s plenty more where that came from, so for this weekend follow-up, what I had to say in that season about four striking moments from the history of Japanese American baseball before and during the Japanese incarceration era:
- Fresno barnstorming in 1927 (part of the First Inning): “It’s vital to note that the Nisei players, even more than their pioneering Issei parents, took the sport very seriously, and quickly developed a reputation as some of the most talented baseball stars in an era defined by the first truly national celebrity players like Babe Ruth. No voice expresses that reputation more clearly than a figure associated with Ruth’s New York Yankees, their scout Ken Wallenberg, who would later note that ‘I always thought that Nisei meant ‘great baseball player’ in Japanese. All the ones I knew certainly fit that description.’ And in October 1927, just after winning the World Series and at the height of their fame with the Yankees, Ruth and his teammate Lou Gehrig played a highly competitive barnstorming game in Frenso against Nisei players, including the powerful slugger [BEN: and two-way star, I just learned right now] Johnny Nakagawa who was known as the ‘Nisei Babe Ruth.’”
- Henry Honda in 1941-2 (also part of the First Inning): “This increasingly fraught period likewise tragically affected individual Nisei players. No player exemplifies those losses more than Henry Honda, a young pitcher from Hawaii who was starring for the San Jose Asahi. In 1941 he was signed by the Cleveland Indians, becoming one of the first Nisei players to sign a contract with a Major League team. But after the Pearl Harbor attack the club withdrew the offer, and Honda ended up in Manzanar incarceration camp. He would recall in an interview with scholar Kerry Yo Nakagawa, ‘You know, I loved baseball then, in the pre-war years and I had a pretty good chance to have a career. I still pitched in the camps and had a pretty good baseball season and career inside the camps, but when I got out my career hopes ended. I loved baseball then and I still love baseball now,’ he concluded tearfully.”
- High school triumph in 1942 (part of the Seventh Inning): “In the top of the Sixth Inning, as part of the section focused on the legendary Dean of the Diamond Kenichi Zenimura, I discussed the Gila River Eagles high school team (including his two talented sons Howard and Harvey) that Zenimura coached to hugely successful seasons throughout their time at that Arizona camp. In Through a Diamond, Kerry Yo Nakagawa tells at length the story of Gila River’s hard-fought, iconic victory over the three-time state champion team from Tucson high school (the Badgers), a powerhouse squad that Camp Director Leroy Bennett apparently believed would dominate the Eagles in this exhibition game played on Zenimura’s famous Gila River diamond. But the Eagles emerged triumphant from this back-and-forth affair, and of young Harvey Zenimura’s bases-loaded, game-winning hit in the bottom of the 10th Inning, his teammate George Kataoka recalls, ‘You know, the Tucson paper said that it was a bloop single that won the game for them. Heck, that was no bloop single. Harvey ripped that ball right between third and shortstop.’…“We can hear in that recollection what this game and victory meant to the young men on the Eagles, as well as the thousands of incarcerated Japanese American spectators cheering for that result. But just as inspiring, and even more important, is what the experience apparently meant for the visiting white players. During a 2006 reunion of the two teams, one of those white players, Bernie Weinstein, admitted that going into the game, ‘In the back of our mind we wanted to make up for Pearl Harbor,’ but then remembers, ‘I saw the fence and said, ‘God, this is like a prison.’ It was a game that most of us will never forget. I realized that these people were Americans, just like myself. The more I thought about it, the more I thought, what a big mistake we made by putting these people in this relocation camp.’ As baseball historian Bill Staples Jr., author of the definitive biography of Kenichi Zenimura, puts it, ‘The two coaches, Zenimura and Hank Slagle, were men ahead of their time. They were trying to teach their ballplayers the concept of shared humanity.’
- A very symbolic victory in 1943 (also part of the Seventh Inning): “No games were more symbolic, however, than those between camp teams and squads composed of prison guards. That was true even when the camp teams lost such contests, as they did in June 1943 at the Rowher incarceration camp in Arkansas; led by a former semi-pro star turned military police sergeant named Burke (again, full name unknown), the guards defeated the Japanese American Royal Dukes 7-1. Even more symbolic, and no doubt significantly more satisfying, was the experience of the 16 talented Japanese American players who in July 1943 traveled the 150 miles from Idaho’s Minidoka camp to the Fifth Annual Idaho State Semi-Professional Tournament in Idaho Falls. After dominating wins in the early rounds, in the tournament quarterfinals the Japanese American squad was matched up with the Hunt Military Police, a team composed of guards from their camp. I don’t know if that was a striking coincidence or a purposeful choice from the tournament organizers, nor what if any the conversations were going into that highly charged affair. But I do know that the Japanese American team won the game going away, dominating the guards by a score of 14-1, perhaps the most iconic and defining victory of any of these deeply symbolic contests between incarcerated players and white teams.”
Next series starts Monday,
Ben
PS. What do you think? Baseball histories or stories you’d share? And if you have a chance to check out my podcast, please let me know your thoughts!

Leave a Reply