[On October 23rd, the MLB World Series got underway. I’ve been thinking about baseball history a ton over the last few years, including for the two seasons of my podcast, so this week I’ll offer some AmericanStudies contexts for baseball playoffs over time. Leading up to a weekend post on takeaways from my latest podcast season!]
On quick AmericanStudies contexts for five stand-out World Series moments.
- A 1932 controversy: In game 3 of the hotly contested World Series between the Cubs and Yankees, Babe Ruth—whom Cubs fans had been pelting all game with actual garbage as well as verbal abuse—angrily pointed at something and then hit a mammoth home run. The question of whether he “called his shot” or was pointing at the Cubs fans or pitcher will forever remain disputed, a reminder of the ambiguities of baseball (like American) history. But one thing that’s not ambiguous? Presidential candidate Franklin D. Roosevelt was in the stands for that moment!
- A 1956 perfecto: Such extra-curricular moments are often ambiguous, but achievements on the diamond can be more clear-up, as is the case with perhaps the single best game ever pitched in the baseball playoffs: Don Larsen’s perfect game in Game 5 of the World Series between his Yankees and the Brooklyn Dodgers. That game is rightly famous, but I’m not sure even most die-hard baseball fans know that that World Series was Jackie Robinson’s final action in the Major Leagues; he struck out to end Brooklyn’s Game 7 loss and shortly thereafter retired to become an executive with the Chock full O’Nuts coffee company.
- A 1970 masterclass: In the Baltimore Orioles’ dominant World Series win over the upstart Cincinnati Reds (led by their fiery young outfielder Pete Rose, who earlier that season had ruined the career of Cleveland catcher Ray Fosse when he ran him over at home plate in the All-Star Game), Brooks Robinson delivered the clear stand-out performance, battling .429 and playing some of the best third-base defense ever recorded. I could talk more about Pete Rose here, but fuck that man—I just wanted an entry dedicated to a defensive masterclass, as it’s an easily overlooked side of the sport that goes a long way toward playoff success.
- A 1989 earthquake: As I highlighted in that prior post on a trio of California earthquakes, the October 1989 Bay Area quake is a moment that no baseball fan who witnessed it will ever forget. For lots of reasons, including that live broadcast and then the delay of a week before the series resumed. But most of all, I’d say that for a 12-year-old fan (and a rabid one at that—I had a childhood pillow which read “Ben is always dreaming about BASEBALL”) the 1989 earthquake was a necessary reminder that there will always be things that are bigger than the game, even at the game’s biggest moments.
- The 2004 Red Sox: But at the same time, some moments remind us that the game itself can be much bigger than a game; and as someone who was living in the Boston area (actually within the city limits) when the Sox finally broke the Curse and won their first World Series in 86 years, I can testify to the manifold and deeply meaningful ways that sports can affect individuals, families, and communities. Such moments can also produce some of our most moving sportswriting, and on that note I’ll end this post and series with a beautiful example: Tom Verducci’s Sports Illustrated essay on the communal meanings of the Sox’s symbolic win.
Special post this weekend,
Ben
PS. What do you think? Baseball histories or stories you’d share?

Leave a Reply