[On October 23rd, the MLB World Series got underway. I’ve been thinking about baseball history a ton over the last few years, including for the two seasons of my podcast, so this week I’ll offer some AmericanStudies contexts for baseball playoffs over time. Leading up to a weekend post on takeaways from my latest podcast season!]
On an understandable frame for the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League (AAGPBL), and why it’s far from the whole story.
First things first: I have to follow up the last paragraph of yesterday’s post by making clear that there had been women’s semi-pro baseball leagues since at least the early 1930s (and likely before), and that many of them had either been entirely Japanese American or featured prominent Japanese American players. I shared stories from those Japanese American women’s leagues as part of both the First and Fourth Innings of my podcast season, and I hope you’ll check them out to learn more about these histories that (as I argued yesterday about Japanese American baseball more broadly) have been frustratingly overlooked as we’ve begun to better remember mid-20th century women’s baseball. (If you want one specific player and team with which to start exploring those histories, you won’t find more compelling ones than Rosie Maruki (Kakuuchi) and the Dusty Chicks.)
With that said, it is nonetheless the case that the AAGPBL was America’s first fully professional women’s baseball league, and the familiar (thanks to the 1992 film A League of Their Own and its two subsequent TV adaptations) story of the league’s founding is to my mind spot-on. In late 1942/early 1943, a group of Major League Baseball owners and executives—including the legendary Branch Rickey and the chewing gum magnate turned Cubs owner Philip K. Wrigley—decided that something needed to be done to keep public interest in the sport high while many of its male players were serving in the armed forces. The result was the creation of this new women’s league, which held its tryouts in the late spring of 1943 and began play with its first four teams (of an eventual 10) on May 30th of that year. (To keep with the week’s series focus on the playoffs, the team with the best first-half record met the team with the best second-half record in the championship series that autumn.) My sense of the collective narrative around the league and its histories has been that we’ve thus understandably tended to parallel it to the symbolic representative of the other most famous WWII shift in women’s roles: Rosie the Riveter.
But as is the case even with the histories we get decently right, there are layers we tend to miss that add a good bit to the story. For one thing, there was a second, competing professional league that began in the following year: the National Girls Baseball League (NGBL), which evolved out of the Chicago amateur Metropolitan League, and featured six teams of its own. And for another thing, and a more important one in terms of changing our understanding of the era, both the AAGPBL and the NGBL in no way dissolved at or after the end of the war; indeed, both leagues continued for another decade, with both closing after the 1954 season (and even briefly merged before they did so, with players from both taking part in the 1952-53 International Girls Baseball League). It’s of course very much likewise the case that many women workers of all types didn’t abruptly leave the workforce after 1945, despite cultural narratives of a return to housewife status in the 1950s; certainly things continued to evolve in the post-war period, but the fundamental fact is that WWII’s changes were enduring ones, and that was as true on the baseball diamond as it was in many other places.
Last playoff contexts tomorrow,
Ben
PS. What do you think? Baseball histories or stories you’d share?

Leave a Reply