October 28, 2026: PlayoffStudying: The “Japanese World Series”

[On October 23rd, the MLB World Series got underway. I’ve been thinking about baseball history a ton over the last few years, including for the two seasons of my podcast, so this week I’ll offer some AmericanStudies contexts for baseball playoffs over time. Leading up to a weekend post on takeaways from my latest podcast season!]

On three things we can learn from a much-touted 1935 series between the barnstorming Tokyo Giants and the hometown Los Angeles Nippons.

One of the most interesting things I learned in researching my new podcast season (on which a lot more this weekend) was how just simultaneously baseball developed in Japan and the United States. Don’t get me wrong, despite the debates over the sport’s invention, it definitely got started in the pre-Civil War U.S.; but it became truly national in the last few decades of the 19th century, and during that same period it was likewise taking off in Japan (and in the place that was at the time a middle-ground between the two nations, Hawaii). At the very least, it’s important to think about the sport as genuinely transnational by the early 20th century, and those cross-Pacific connections were the direct motivation for the Tokyo Giants’ lengthy 1935 barnstorming trip to the Western United States and Canada between. As that last hyperlinked post convincingly argues, the Japanese newspaperman and baseball zealot Sotaro Suzuki had been blown away by the reception that a 1934 American barnstorming team (headlined by Babe Ruth) had received in his nation. He believed returning the favor would help Japanese players strengthen their game and further cement the sport’s place in his culture, and made that dream a reality with the 1935 tour.

When we take a look at that thorough itinerary for the Giants’ 1935 tour, it becomes quickly apparent that the “Japanese World Series,” as the April 13th tripleheader between the Giants and the famous Los Angeles Nippon barnstorming team was billed, was not particularly distinct from the rest of the tour. (Indeed, the Giants played another game in Los Angeles the next day, against the white team Pirrone that hailed from the famous California Winter League). I’m a bit ashamed to admit that when I first read about the Japanese World Series, I thought of it as a pretty distinct and big occasion, and still largely framed it as such in the First Inning of my podcast season (to be fair, I believe the excellent book in which I encountered it, Kerry Yo Nakagawa’s Through a Diamond: 100 Years of Japanese American Baseball, did present the games that way as well). For all of us who are interested in sports histories, it’s worth keeping in mind how much publicity and marketing can play into how particular events were presented and thus are remembered; that’s of course true of most historical events in one way or another (our sense of them comes mostly from the stories that were, have been, and are told, rather than whatever actually happened in the past), but it’s doubly the case when we’re talking about events that were looking to draw in audiences, sell tickets, and so on.

Yet at the same time, I think it’s just as important not to be cynical about such events, or at least to remain open to more genuine and inspiring reasons behind the narratives. As a result of researching, writing, and sharing this podcast season, I’ve thought a lot about the gap between the amazing talents and impressive successes of early 20th century Japanese American baseball players, teams, and leagues and the general lack of awareness of that part of baseball history, even from many die-hard fans of the sport. (For just five of those phenomenal Japanese American players, check out this Bluesky thread I created in context of this season’s MLB All-Star Game.) Even in their own era, I have to imagine that they felt frustratingly overshadowed by the Major Leagues and perhaps even by the Negro Leagues (fully professional as they were), even though in neither case were those leagues necessarily comprised of more talent than the concurrent Japanese American leagues. Which is to say, Japanese American players and teams weren’t given the chance to be part of the more official “World Series” of the 1930s, so it makes all the sense in the world that they would use that symbolic phrase to describe a high-powered series of games of their own.

Next playoff contexts tomorrow,

Ben

PS. What do you think? Baseball histories or stories you’d share?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

×